Vivian I. Buhain
Jocelyn R. Lorenzo
New Era University
How to cite:
Buhain, V. I., & Lorenzo, J. R. (2024). Teachers’ lived experiences in teaching fundamental research writing to senior high school students. NEU Likha Journal: A Refereed Journal of the New Era University School of Graduate Studies, 1(2), 58–88.
Abstract
This phenomenological study explored the lived experiences of teachers in teaching fundamental research to Senior High School students. Despite innovating a variety of strategies that enabled teachers to customize according to individual learning needs for the students to express their own identity as writers, the participants still encountered challenges in teaching fundamental research writing. Thus, this study aimed to gain a deeper understanding of these challenges faced by teachers in this context and the strategies they employed to enhance student learning. Seven (7) themes were uncovered: writing skills development, learning opportunities for improvement, teachers’ challenges dealing with diversified culture, moods and cultural context, individual differences and teaching methods, self-reflection and research, and evaluating sources and providing concept guide. Importantly, various strategies were determined for curriculum revisions and support systems. On the whole, this study underscored the participants’ challenges as they faced an array of students’ setbacks in demonstrating the fundamentals in research writing in terms of grammatical structure, paraphrasing, paragraphing, in-text citations and formatting research. Challenges were also evident in students’ lack of motivation, maintaining focus, fear of writing and the need for support. On the other hand, the participants highlighted some learners’ exceptional communication skills and persistence to complete one’s research but had difficulties demonstrating research writing skills.
Keywords: lived experiences, teachers, research, Senior High School, pedagogy, qualitative study, professional development, student
engagement
Introduction
The role of teachers in shaping the academic development and learning experiences of students is paramount. Particularly in the context
of senior high school education, where students are preparing for higher
academic pursuits, the guidance and mentorship provided by teachers play
a crucial role in nurturing their skills and abilities. One area of significant importance is the teaching of research writing, which equips students with
the essential skills to communicate effectively, think critically, and engage
in scholarly discourse.
In a previous study conducted by Paurillo (2019) with selected
senior high school teachers who teach research as participants, findings
reveal that in terms of their students’ competence in research writing, they
normally knew the fundamentals in writing. On the contrary, these teachers
encountered challenges in teaching the subject, particularly the rudiments of
writing. Another study regarding teaching research conducted by Capulso & Sicat (2019) disclosed that students were considered incompetent and
struggled to construct sentences and paragraphs. If they were, they could
hardly observe coherence and cohesion of ideas. They lacked the sense of
urgency of learning the subject and normally they do not submit on time.
Findings included inability to use appropriate words and express their
thoughts, poor vocabulary foundation, and failure in building research
concepts. As a result, they were not ready to pursue qualitative research
because of their inability to express their thoughts in words.
Meanwhile, Kim et al. (2021) provided insights into the effectiveness
of writing instruction for Grade 6-12 students. They investigated the impact
of writing interventions on students’ writing skills using experimental and
quasi- experimental designs. Research writing to senior high school students
can offer valuable insights into the challenges, strategies, and innovations
in pedagogy within this domain. These experiences encompass the day-to-day interactions, instructional practices, and reflective processes that shape
the teaching and learning of research writing in the classroom. Experts
in the field of education underscore the significance of teachers’ lived
experiences in influencing student outcomes and educational practices.
Despite the insights provided by experts, there remains a need to explore the lived experiences of teachers in teaching research writing to senior high school students in specific cultural contexts.
Therefore, this research sought to explore the lived experiences of teachers teaching research writing to senior high school student and examine the influence of cultural context on instructional practices and the essence of
these experiences for innovating metacognitive strategies in teaching research writing. By shedding light on these aspects, this study aimed to contribute valuable insights to the field of education and inform the development of effective teaching practices in senior high school settings.
It aimed to understand the challenges and insights gained from
teaching research, particularly in developing students’ ability to write
effectively. Additionally, it examined how the cultural context influences
teachers’ experiences and the strategies they employ to overcome difficulties
in teaching research writing. The study investigated the significance of
these lived experiences in shaping and innovating metacognitive strategies
to enhance the teaching and learning process of research writing.
The literature highlighted several key challenges and considerations
in teaching research writing to senior high school students. Academic
writing poses significant difficulties for students due to a lack of handson
practice, weak vocabulary, and struggles with grammar and coherence.
Additionally, motivating students to appreciate research is another hurdle,
as many exhibit low comprehension skills and minimal engagement
in research activities. Creating a conducive learning environment is
crucial in addressing these issues, especially with the implementation
of a research-oriented curriculum that fosters critical thinking and
problem-solving skills. However, teachers often face teaching difficulties
alongside mental and emotional upheavals, which can affect their ability to effectively guide students. To enhance growth in research education, continuous professional development, mentoring, and training in research
methodologies are necessary. The guidance of passionate researchers, such
as research mentors, critique panels, and resource speakers, has been found
to positively influence students’ research performance. Lastly, the role of
educators in addressing students’ low aptitude and lack of motivation is
vital. By recognizing individual learning needs and implementing targeted
strategies, teachers can foster a more supportive and engaging learning
experience, ultimately improving students’ research writing skills.
Method
Research Design
Transcendental phenomenology is rooted in the principles identified by Edmund Husserl in 1913 (Husserl, 2000) and later refined into a qualitative research method by Clark Moustakas (Moustakas, 1994). Husserl’s concept of transcendental phenomenology seeks to move beyond superficial interpretation to uncover the essence of social phenomena. This methodology prioritizes the participants’ descriptions of their experiences rather than the researchers’ interpretations. By analyzing various participant experiences, a structural description was developed, outlining the conditions, situations, and contexts that define the essence of their lived experiences. To effectively gather relevant data, the researcher employed an interview guide, enabling a comprehensive evaluation of participants’ perspectives, particularly in relation to senior high school students’ experiences with writing research papers.
Participants
This study utilized purposive sampling to select five (5) research educators actively teaching senior high school students in District 1, Marikina City. The participants were chosen based on their experience and expertise, having taught research for more than two years. Selection criteria emphasized educators who exhibited a strong commitment to innovative teaching strategies, provided meaningful guidance and motivation to students, and actively pursued professional growth. These attributes were considered essential for enhancing student engagement and improving research learning outcomes. The selected participants’ in-depth knowledge and practical experience positioned them as valuable contributors to understanding effective research teaching practices within the specified educational context.
Procedure
Data collection for this study involved multiple qualitative techniques,
including interviews, arts-based methods, classroom observations, and
reflective diaries. The phenomenological in-depth interview served as the
primary data collection tool, allowing the researchers to elicit rich narratives
from participants. Following Moustakas’ (1994) approach, the study focused
on understanding both “what” participants experienced and “how” they
experienced it. Five (5) participants voluntarily participated in individual
interviews after providing informed consent. These semi-structured, open-ended interviews allowed educators to elaborate on their teaching styles,
experiences, and perspectives regarding research instruction.
In addition to interviews, classroom observations provided further insights into participants’ teaching practices. Observation, as emphasized by Tannenbaum & Spradley (1980), enabled researchers to explore cultural
knowledge that shapes behavior and interpretation. This approach allowed
the researchers to identify key pedagogical strategies, instructional
challenges, and engagement techniques used by the educators. The
researcher also incorporated arts-based methods and diary reflections to
capture additional dimensions of participants’ experiences, enhancing the
depth of qualitative data.
Data Analysis
Moustakas’ phenomenological research method guided the data
analysis process, ensuring a holistic and systematic approach. This
method focused primarily on describing participants’ lived experiences
rather than interpreting them. Additionally, Husserl’s concept of epoche,
or bracketing, was applied, requiring the researcher to set aside personal
biases, preconceived notions, and prior experiences to adopt a fresh
perspective on the phenomenon under study. Moustakas (1994) defines
transcendental phenomenology as perceiving experiences with openness
and objectivity, which was crucial in analyzing the participants’ narratives.
The data analysis process began with the identification of commonalities across participants’ responses. These responses were coded and categorized into themes, reflecting the underlying structures of their experiences. The final thematic analysis provided a structured description of participants’ experiences, emphasizing the conditions, situations, and contextual factors influencing their teaching practices. Through continuous reflection on subjectivity, the researchers ensured that interpretations were minimized, and data were presented as authentically as possible. Bracketing played a key role in maintaining an open and receptive approach, allowing for a more comprehensive understanding of the research phenomenon.
Ethical Considerations
Ethical considerations were carefully observed throughout the research process. Informed consent was obtained from all participating teachers, who were provided with a letter of consent detailing the study’s purpose and procedures. Their identities were safeguarded through the use of pseudonyms, ensuring confidentiality and anonymity. Participants were
assured of their privacy rights and given the option to withdraw from the
study at any time without consequences. Prior to the interviews, ethical
guidelines were explained, reinforcing the commitment to maintaining
integrity, respect, and ethical responsibility in conducting the study.
Results and Discussion
The researcher conducted in-depth interviews with participants to
obtain valuable insights. The data collection phase involved interviews
averaging nearly three hours, ensuring comprehensive responses and
detailed information. A set of teacher-made interview questions was
designed to elicit diverse perspectives from participants. Various
tools, such as Google Meet screen sharing and real-time messaging
via Messenger, enhanced the data collection experience. Additionally,
arts-based techniques were utilized, incorporating photos as visual
representations of the participants’ teaching styles. Observational data
collection also played a crucial role in enriching the study. Throughout
the process, ethical considerations, including participant confidentiality
and data security, were strictly upheld to maintain research integrity.
After data collection, the researcher conducted an in-depth analysis
to extract meaningful insights, which significantly contributed to shaping
strategies for teaching research writing to senior high school students.
Although the process posed challenges, particularly in terms of time
constraints and participants’ commitment, the researchers maintained
composure and focus from beginning to end. This section presents the
themes derived from the participants’ subjective experiences in teaching
fundamental research writing.
Theme 1: Writing skills development
Category 1: Writing abilities and achieving quality
Teachers should be first knowledgeable with the fundamentals of writing skills, such as paragraphing, grammar accuracy, paraphrasing, and citing sources which they impart to their students in an interesting and engaging manner, inculcating their students to display focus and control in doing their tasks as many students still need enough attention and guidance. During the interviews, participants, “Wijay”, “Dionee”, “Charm”, and “Lala”, attributed this issue as a setback to students’ research writing.
Achieving accuracy in writing has been a never-ending classroom encounter in teaching research. Teaching higher-level processes doesn’t have to wait for students to master lower-level ones. In fact, encouraging students to write will boost their chances of learning both high and low-level abilities (Arrimada et al., 2019). Similarly, the study by Rio et al. (2021) sheds light on the challenges faced by teachers in teaching research, particularly in the areas of difficulties in teaching and mental and emotional disturbances. This highlights the significant impact that the teaching of research can have on educators and underscores the need foradequate support and resources to address these challenges.
Category 2: Expectations and writing opportunities
Teachers have varying expectations for students’ writing performance, and it is paramount that, based on these expectations, they need to give their students adequate writing opportunities to prove their potential and
abilities. Participants responded with insightful ideas during the interview.
In their investigation of the methods used to enhance students’ research
writing abilities, Smith et al. (2020) highlighted the need to offer thorough
instruction on the principles of academic writing. The importance of giving
students the skills they need to successfully negotiate the challenges of
research writing is emphasized by the participant. These skills include
proper citation practices, coherence, and grammatical precision.
Category 3: Acquiring new knowledge
Incorporating an art-based technique using an image to represent a teacher who believes in having a passion for education and employs various strategies in teaching to acquire new knowledge can visually enhance
the reflection on the importance of continuous learning and professional
development in developing teachers’ writing skills. Ventista & Brown
(2023) stated that professional development activities, such as participation
in seminars, workshops, and webinars, significantly influenced educators’
knowledge acquisition and skill development in research writing. The
study highlighted the importance of continuous learning opportunities and
collaboration in improving teachers’ writing skills and supporting students
research projects. As presented, the importance of continuous learning
and professional development in developing teachers’ writing skills is an
utmost concern in the educational process.
Category 4: Keeping composed and determined
Teachers’ ability to keep one’s composure and stay determined contributes to students’ constructive learning outcomes and experiences. Rovikasari & Suproyadi (2020) investigated teachers’ attitudes and practices towards discovery learning and teachers’ challenges in instructional writing. The results showed that the participants had a negative attitude towards writing skills but a positive attitude towards discovery learning in teaching writing.
Category 5: Discipline, focus, and goal-oriented
When teachers impose discipline, they can set a higher level of
expectations and provide more writing opportunities as students could
stay focused and goal-oriented. In the study by Landicho (2020), results
indicate that most students have no previous experience writing formal research papers or laboratory reports. Despite this, the respondents
considered the importance of research in developing critical thinking,
solving real problems and creating a sense of satisfaction. The central
motives of the research are teachers’ expectations and personal desire to
grow, succeed and get good grades.
Theme 2: Learning opportunities for improvement
Category 1: Supportive classroom environment
Establishing a healthy and positive learning environment impacts
the students’ response to teachers’ strategies in teaching. Teachers should
include a variety of writing activities that employ a supportive learning
environment during classroom discussion. For instance, this result supports Paurillo’s (2019) study which gave emphasis to senior high school students being required to present write-ups of the scientific inquiry process, draft experiments, business concepts, marketing ideas, essays on current social issues, critique papers, project plans, livelihood projects, and other such summative assessments. In general, the implementation of a science-based curriculum in secondary schools is in line with global educational trends that prioritize critical thinking, research skills and experiential learning. The study of Smith et al. (2020), explored the impact of providing ample writing opportunities in the classroom on student engagement and the quality of papers produced. It examined how strategies such as reminding students of writing components, selecting topics of interest, and leveraging weaknesses positively contribute to enhancing students’ writing skills and outcomes. The focus on creating a supportive classroom environment that addresses students’ difficulties in understanding writing fundamentals, encourages quality paper production, and provides diverse writing opportunities is crucial for fostering student engagement and improving writing outcomes.
Category 2: Regular feedback
Teachers should foster administering regular feedback on students’
writing, including addressing their fear of writing, reminding them of the
components of writing, emphasizing the use of strong verbs, engaging in
research activities to develop research writing skills, and assisting with
reconstructing paragraph ideas, is essential for enhancing their writing
proficiency, confidence, and keeping organized.
Significantly then, feedback connected within that process needs to
be useful to the learner that is understandable, sufficiently detailed, and
usable in order to affect chance (Henderson et al., 2019). Feedback helps
instructors inculcate critical thinking regarding academic assessment; its
effectiveness depends upon how it is presented (Niu & You, 2019). Similarly,
Kilag et al. (2023) underscored the importance of collaborative teaching and
learning, providing holistic support for students, incorporating innovative
teaching and learning approaches, and emphasizing student assessment and
evaluation to achieve success in senior high school education.
Category 3: Background research behavior
Teachers’ understanding of students’ background behavior towards
research is crucial in addressing challenges such as lack of motivation, difficulty finding quality sources, developing research writing skills,
maintaining focus, lack of confidence in writing, fear of writing, and
the need for support. By selecting topics of interest, recognizing reliable
sources, providing writing opportunities, fostering dedication, and offering
clarification, teachers can effectively support students in their research
writing endeavors.
Students’ emotions, both good and bad, regarding their education
and assignments are referred to as “emotional.” According to Iruka et
al. (2019), a student’s emotional involvement is determined by their
emotions, connections to school, and sense of value and belonging. These
factors encourage students to complete their assignments. Burroughs et
al. (2019), in their study of the impact of teacher effectiveness on student
outcomes, explored what makes up good teaching strategies and how they
affect learning outcomes and student accomplishment. They provided
insightful information regarding the relationship between student behavior
and teacher comprehension in the context of research writing.
Category 4: Engage in professional growth
Incorporating art-based techniques, such as using images to represent
the teacher’s teaching style, can emphasize a creative and visual element
to the reflection on the teacher’s commitment to supporting student growth
and fostering a positive learning environment. Ventista & Brown (2023)
emphasized that participation in professional development activities, such
as applying for mentorship, participating in workshops, and participating
in reflective practices, positively affects educators’ teaching effectiveness and student outcomes. The study highlighted the importance of continuous
learning opportunities and collaboration in promoting professional growth
and improving teaching practices.
Category 5: Turning disappointments to positive ones
While teachers may have experienced a variety of disappointments,
their profound intention to teach will enable them to find ways and means
to turn their frustrations to constructive ones. As reviewed, teacher ideologies and student participation were found to be key elements of classroom activities important to achieving desired learning outcomes (Wang et al., 2022). Meanwhile, Paurillo (2019) reported that students lack motivation for research writing and a minimum score was found for interest in writing. On the other hand, 100% of the students thought that the answer to the challenges is to use different motivational activities when writing a research paper. This transforms the teacher’s role into a clear and stimulating discussion of research writing in the classroom through fun tasks as being crucial.
Theme 3: Teachers’ challenges with diversified culture
Category 1: Cultural context and communication styles
Teachers faced challenges in dealing with diversified cultures,
including navigating ways of communicating, valuing different communication types, understanding ways of asking and answering, managing expectations of reactions, being aware of cultural backgrounds, and developing effective strategies to promote cultural inclusivity in the classroom. Students’ willingness to participate during classroom discussions is also a manifestation of different communication styles as influenced by cultural backgrounds. Cultural context may not just be defined by students’ cultural background outside the classroom but also by what exists inside the classroom. Culture has an impact on learning, particularly when it comes to applying abstract information into useful applications.
According to Brion (2021), learning is influenced by culture, particularly when learning is transferred from abstract concepts to real world applications. The challenges teachers face in dealing with diversified cultures underscore the importance of cultural competence and sensitivity in educational settings.
Category 2: Cultural sensitivity
Incorporating a visual representation of an enthusiastic teacher surrounded by a diverse group, symbolizing unique strands and backgrounds, can visually enhance the reflection on teachers’ challenges with diversified culture and the significance of cultural sensitivity in teaching practices. Cultural sensitivity in teaching practices involves recognizing and respecting students’ individualities, adapting teaching approaches to diverse communication styles, and providing additional support to help all students fully engage and meet high expectations. The importance of cultural sensitivity in teaching practices and highlighted the positive effect of adapting teaching methods to different cultural backgrounds of students. The study by Naz et al. (2024) found that teachers who demonstrated cultural sensitivity and adapted their teaching methods to the needs of diverse learners reported better student engagement, academic achievement, and overall classroom dynamics.
Category 3: Strong conviction and intentional teaching
Educators’ intentional drive to help students develop research skills also
lies in how equipped they are with teaching methods that will tailor students
to meaningful learning experiences. According to Hajian (2019), teaching
activities are the basic activities of the learning process in which teachers
carry out knowledge transfer to students. Different methods can be used in the learning process. Different methods are adapted according to the needs and characteristics of the students. Media and technology, such as ProWritingAid program, are used to make learning more interesting and considered effective in improving the writing skills of senior high school students.
Category 4: Non- verbal cues demonstrating patience, hard work, and confidence
Nonverbal cues displaying teachers’ patience and hard work,
influenced by the cultural context, play a key role in creating a positive
and supportive learning environment for senior high school students
during research training. Research by Cabatac et al. (2023) on non-verbal
communication in education highlighted that teachers’ non-verbal cues,
such as eye contact, facial expressions, and body posture, significantly
impact student engagement and academic performance, particularly in
culturally diverse classrooms.
Theme 4: Moods and cultural context
Inculcating constructive moods with individual differences is
crucial in classroom interaction.
Category 1: Acquiring research skills and learning values
Teachers’ reactions are significantly influenced by their students’
moods, which can be positively impacted by interactions that practice
respectful communication, the creation of learning opportunities, consideration of individual learning styles based on the educational strand,
the value placed on respect for authority, the recognition of individual
autonomy, and the understanding that individual learning values are
shaped by cultural contexts. According to Gamage et al. (2021), values
are the underlying attitudes, behaviors, and beliefs that society has long
recognized as morally righteous. They are seen as the virtues that an
individual possesses in their life in the broadest sense.
Category2: Constructive moods and meaningful learning
Constructive moods and meaningful learning are fostered through
interactions that practice respectful communication, value patience,
provide explicit instructions, and uplift moods to enhance engagement
and participation. Different learning values influenced by cultural
contexts play a significant role in shaping the educational experience
and promoting a positive learning environment. For Scherer & Moors
(2019), emotions have extremely elusive scientific definitions that are
difficult to test practically. Their definition of emotions is grounded in a
multi-component theory that maintains emotions are mirrored in action tendencies, coherent, synchronized patterns of reactions of the peripheralphysiological and central nervous systems, and integrated into subjective experiences through the use of voice, gestures, and facial expressions. However, for McKasy (2020), negative emotions, on the other hand, hinder performance on difficult tasks since they are associated with limited and shallow information.
Category 3: Achieving full potential
Imagine an artwork that showcases a classroom setting where
students are engaged in reflective practices and receiving guidance
through coaching. The visual representation features students actively
participating in discussions, reflecting on their learning needs, and taking
proactive steps to enhance their research and writing abilities. The teacher
depicted as a supportive figure, is guiding and empowering students to
thrive academically and reach their full potential. The coaching approach
fosters a supportive and empowering learning environment, allowing
students to thrive and achieve their full potential. Teaching activities are
the core activities in the learning process, where there is a transfer of
knowledge carried out by teachers to students. Various methods can be
used in the learning process. The various methods are adapted to the needs
and characteristics of students. This highlights the transformative impact
of coaching and reflective practices in empowering students to excel in
their research and writing endeavors, ultimately enabling them to reach
their academic goals and realize their full potential (Hajian, 2019).
Theme 5: Individual differences and teaching methods
This part emphasized the importance of individual differences and teaching methods.
Category 1: Cultural context and learning styles
In education, individual differences customize teaching methods by considering cultural context and learning styles. Adapting teaching methods to determine students’ learning preferences and developing effective teaching strategies tailored to individual needs are crucial. Teachers should integrate valuing respectful interaction, understanding diverse learning methods and values, into teaching practices to enhance student engagement and academic success. According to Wang et al. (2021), with content presented according to each student’s unique learning needs, personalized learning can enhance the significance of the educational experience. This strategy can increase students’ motivation to learn by giving them more freedom and accountability for their educational journey. They added that students are given more autonomy and accountability in their learning with this individualized approach. Furthermore, information distribution can be facilitated in a variety of ways with the use of digital platforms, taking individual learner characteristics into account.
Category 2: Learning materials to cater learning needs
Identifying learning materials to cater to learning needs involves
being aware of students’ interests and customizing teaching methods to
align with individual preferences. By recognizing students’ interests and
tailoring learning materials to their needs, educators can create a more
engaging and effective learning experience. It is crucial to make sure that neither educators nor students are duped into believing that lectures are
the most effective choice for learning. In light of this, the students may not
be more responsible for their own education. The process of identifying
learning materials to cater to learning needs requires a deep awareness of
students’ interests and preferences (Deslauriers et al., 2019).
Category 3: Progress and the value of resilience
Integrating an art-based technique through visual presentation can
enhance the idea of providing additional support for students and fostering
resilience in academic endeavors. Providing additional support for students
in setting goals, monitoring progress, and engaging in self-reflection fosters
resilience and progress in their academic endeavors. According to Affuso
et al. (2022), students who received additional support in goal setting,
progress monitoring, and self-reflection showed greater flexibility and
progress in their academic work. Teachers who demonstrated enthusiasm
for education and used effective strategies engaged students into creating a
positive learning environment that fostered student resilience and success.
Category 4: Demonstrating understanding
Demonstrating understanding through non-verbal cues is essential
for tailoring teaching methods to accommodate individual differences
among senior high school students in research education. Research
by Keelson et al. (2024) on non-verbal communication in education
emphasized that teachers’ non-verbal behaviors, such as active listening
and empathetic gestures, contribute to creating a supportive learning
environment that caters to individual student needs and preferences.
Theme 6: Self-reflection and research skills
The value of self-reflection is crucial in developing research skills.
Category 1: Self-reflection and research engagement
Self-reflection plays a vital role in developing research skills by
explicitly teaching the research process to demonstrate metacognition,
providing resource materials, modeling good research practices, sharing
research experiences with students, offering opportunities to demonstrate
research skills. Heng & Chu (2023) suggested fostering teachers’ selfefficacy,
reflection, and resilience can contribute to increasing their work
engagement. Self-reflection is a powerful tool in the development of
research skills, allowing students to assess their strengths and weaknesses
in the research process.
Category 2: Modeling research practices
Effective research practices in education involve modeling good research practices, sharing research experiences, providing opportunities to practice conducting research, offering constructive feedback, encouraging self-awareness, and utilizing a variety of research methods.
Different academics have concentrated on the learning outcomes of the pupils in various situations. Sulasmi (2021), for example, demonstrated that modeling learning practices is beneficial in helping students develop and meet their learning objectives. Furthermore, for any true learning process to occur, interaction is essential. Learning is dynamic, and interactions involving cognitive processes produce learning results.
Category 3: The purpose of teaching
Practicing self-reflection and honing research skills as an educator are essential to promoting purposeful teaching. By thinking about teaching practices and continually improving their research skills, educators can
increase enthusiasm and purpose in their role, leading to a more meaningful
and effective teaching experience. Seeing oneself as an enthusiastic teacher
surrounded by a diverse student body symbolizes a commitment to inclusion,
diversity, and individualized learning experiences in the classroom.
Part of the teaching purpose is to demonstrate teaching skills in
subjects assigned to teachers. These participants have been continuously
monitored by their principals. A call for greater mentoring, modeling, and
enhanced research underscores the importance of continuing professional
development for teachers.
Category 4: Pros and cons of independence
Utilizing non-verbal cues to analyze the pros and cons of research
methods and outcomes can enhance self-reflection and research skills
development among senior high school students in the context of research
education. The impact of non-verbal communication in research education
revealed that teachers’ non-verbal cues, such as facial expressions and
gestures indicating critical thinking, can stimulate students’ analytical
thinking and enhance their ability to reflect on research processes
effectively (Keelson et al., 2024).
Theme 7: Evaluating sources and providing concept guide
The ability of evaluating resources and concept guides is beneficial
in producing quality paper.
Category 1: Evaluating engaging and efficient resources
Evaluating sources and providing concept guides in education involves
offering specific guidance and feedback, providing structured concept guides, and engaging in extensive guiding and monitoring to ensure comprehension, control, and reflection. By implementing these strategies, educators can support students in developing critical thinking skills, enhancing their understanding of sources, and fostering a deeper level of comprehension and reflection. Lucas et al. (2021) claimed that gamification and simulation can make a study more enjoyable because they forecast positive future trends and yield positive results. Other benefits of simulation and gamification for research include student grouping, research critiques, seminars, library visits and work activities, proposal defenses, final defenses, and worksheet activities that are assigned throughout the semester.
Category 2. Concept guide and manifesting control
In education, providing concept guides are essential for effective
learning. This involves offering specific guidance and feedback, providing
structured concept guides, and engaging in extensive guiding and
monitoring to enhance students’ comprehension, control, and reflection,
ultimately fostering a deeper level of understanding and critical thinking.
Research provides necessary information in the field of work and in
anything under the sun. It also helps people get acquainted with the process
and in the successful outcome of a project. Through these practices, educators can create a supportive and enriching learning environment that
nurtures students’ intellectual growth and fosters a culture of inquiry and
self-directed learning (Abinan, 2021).
Category 3: Different approaches and time
Utilizing various approaches over time in education can lead to the
manifestation of control and persistence in teachers’ teaching journeys.
Teachers can employ mastery of strategies from which they themselves
can reflect, implement and take control. The study of Qureshi et al. (2021)
underscored the importance of collaborative teaching and learning,
providing holistic support for students, incorporating innovative teaching
and learning approaches. Lucas et al. (2021) found that students excel
in research performance when they receive mentoring from passionate
individuals, guidance on research activities, and work collaboratively
with their group members. However, challenges arise when there is a
clash of ideas among group members, insufficient literature reviews, and
time-consuming literary works. Recommendations include forming group
friendships with similar interests, streamlining research materials, and
ensuring online access to necessary literature.
Category 4: Work assignments and learning process
Visualize an art piece depicting the educator standing confidently
in front of a class with eyes wide open and exuding leadership and guidance. Empowering students to become subject matter experts through teaching research formats and fostering resilience and discipline in their work assignments can enhance their learning process and instill the value of research in both personal and academic contexts. By guiding students
to approach assignments with resilience and discipline educators can help
them recognize the significance of their work and its impact on their overall
learning journey. In their study, Lucas et al. (2021) found that the following
factors help students produce high-quality research output: “guidance
from someone who is passionate about research” as indicated by their
research critique, research instructor, resource speaker of the completed
seminar, and group members; “instructions for something or activities to
be done” such as sample library visit surveys, answer worksheets, and
research defenses; and “teamwork” between group members.
Category 5: Evaluative thinking and professional guidance
Non-verbal cues that convey evaluative thinking play a crucial
role in guiding students in evaluating sources and providing conceptual
guidance in research education. In a study by Subekti (2020) in which
teacher training was held, the first session focused on relevant theories,
practical suggestions, and examples regarding research questions, which
were presented to the participants. This session, despite being resource-person-led, could be interrupted with immediate questions from the teacher
participants, allowing a more dynamic discussion. The second session
was a workshop session in which the participants practiced formulating
research questions based on their respective teaching contexts with close
guidance from the resource person. The reflective evaluation on the
training revealed several conclusions on what had gone well and what
needed to be improved along with several suggestions regarding possible
follow-up training in the future.
Conclusion
Teachers have a significant role in cultivating a supportive and
enriching learning environment that enhances students’ writing abilities,
academic growth, and research skills. By providing guidance, constructive
feedback, and encouragement, they empower students to take responsibility
for their learning and develop independence. Beyond instruction, teachers
instill essential values such as discipline, perseverance, and respect,
fostering an inclusive and engaging classroom atmosphere. Their dedication
to continuous professional development, effective teaching strategies, and
the use of research resources further demonstrates their commitment to
student success. This study underscores the profound impact of teachers
in shaping students’ academic achievements, critical thinking skills, and
overall development in research writing.
References
Affuso, G., Zannone, A., Esposito, C., Pannone, M., Miranda, M. C., De Angelis, G., Aquilar, S., Dragone, M., & Bacchini, D. (2022). The effects of teacher support, parental monitoring, motivation, and self-efficacy on academic performance over time. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 38, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10212-021-00594-6
Abinan, A. (2021). Research exposure, attitude towards research, and research competence of senior high school teachers. International Journal of Arts, Sciences and Education, 1(2), 198–218.
Arrimada, M., Torrance, M., & Fidalgo, R. (2019). Effects of teaching planning strategies to first-grade writers. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 89(4), 670–688. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjep.12251
Burroughs, N., Gardner, J., Lee, Y., Guo, S., Touitou, I., Jansen, K., & Schmidt, W. (2019). A review of the literature on teacher effectiveness and student outcomes. In N. Burroughs, J. Gardner, Y. Lee, S. Guo, I. Touitou, K. Jansen, & W. Schmidt (Eds.), Teaching for excellence and equity: Analyzing teacher characteristics, behaviors and student outcomes with TIMSS (pp. 7–17). Springer International Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-16151-4_2
Brion, C. (2021). Culture impacts learning—And not just for students (EJ1290748). ERIC. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1290748
Cabatac, R., Atienza, S. M., Gareza, E. J., Junsay, K., & Olmedo, M. (2023). Exploration of non-verbal features and functions among secondary teachers in the Philippines. Psychology and Education: A Multidisciplinary Journal, 15(1), 14–25. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10116972
Capulso, L. B., & Sicat, A. T. (2019). Nemo dat quod non habet: The lived experience of senior high school teachers teaching practical research subjects. Journal NX, 6(06), 1–11.
Deslauriers, L., McCarty, L. S., Miller, K., Callaghan, K., & Kestin, G. (2019). Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 116(39), 19251–19257. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1821936116
